letters to a young poet

Further, these letters were written during a key period of Rilke's early artistic development after his reputation as a poet began to be established with the publication of parts of Das Stunden-Buch (The Book of Hours) and Das Buch der Bilder (The Book of Images). I guess this little book is the original and "the real thing" equivalent of Coelho's pseudophilosophical, pseudoinspirational manuals. These letters (to a young man he never even met!) Published in 1929, Letters to a Young Poet (Briefe an einen jungen Dichter) by classic German poet Rainer Maria Rilke is a post-humorous manifesto on the creative life. The first of Rainer Maria Rilke's Letters to a Young Poet is evidently a response to a letter written to Rilke by the Young Poet. “Believe in a love that is being stored up for you like an inheritance, and have faith that in this love … If you are to suggest, which translator does best to bring out the real essence of this book? [4] He was approached by the academy's chaplain, Horacek, who noted that Rilke had been a pupil years earlier at the academy's lower school at Sankt Pölten. Kappus compiled and published the letters in 1929—three years after Rilke's death from leukemia. [4][5] Rilke did not continue his military education. [2], In 1929, Franz Xaver Kappus compiled ten letters that he received from Rainer Maria Rilke that were written from 1902 to 1908 and published them under the title Briefe an einen jungen Dichter (Letters to a Young Poet) through Insel Verlag in Leipzig. This exchange of letters began in 1903 thanks to a missive that Franz Xaver Kappus sent to R. M. Rilke, and continued for many years, until 1908. This event was organised by the Kings Place group, Chamberstudio, and the panel included two other poets, Martha Kapos and Denise Riley, musicians Mark Padmore, Amarins Weirdsma and Sini Simonen and composer Sally Beamish. About ten pages into this book, though, I gave up underlining as nearly every sentence was a combination of beauty and wisdom. Three years after Rilke’s death, Kappus assembled and published the letters entitled, Letters to a Young Poet (Briefe an einen jungen Dichter) in 1929. Written in Paris, France on 17 February 1903 - Theme of letter: Criticism fails to "touch a work of art." Rilke provided the young Kappus very little in criticism or in suggestions for his improvement as a poet. Twelve years on and it will have been a ten. 'Letters to a Young Poet' is a book that one can read, and re-read, over the course of a lifetime. I have found out that I far prefer Mr. Rilke's poetry, to his prose. Letters to a Young Poet, by Rainer Maria Rilke, is a gem of a book.It consists of ten letters written to a young man who wrote to Rilke for advice on how to become a successful poet. The older artist, Rainer Maria Rilke (1875–1926), replied to the novice in this series of letters—an amazing archive of remarkable insights into the ideas behind Rilke's greatest poetry. The collection does not include Kappus' letters to Rilke, though the original German collection does include one sonnet of Kappus' own that Rilke sent back to him in Rilke's handwriting with the instruction to "Read the lines as if they were unknown to you, and you will feel in your inmost self how very much they are yours. #2, Rilke, the son of an Austrian army officer, had studied at the academy's lower school at Sankt Pöltenin the 1890s. Start by marking “Letters to a Young Poet” as Want to Read: Error rating book. ", Aside from his role in writing to Rilke and later publishing these letters, Franz Xaver Kappus (1883–1966) is largely forgotten by history. $4.50. About ten pages into this book, though, I gave up underlining as nearly every sentence was a combination of beauty and wisdom. A desire to be and do, whatever the life area, can be assessed by the wisdom contained herein. The ten letters reproduced here were written during an important stage in Rilke's artistic development, and they contain many of the themes that later appeared in his best works. At the start of the twentieth century, Rainer Maria Rilke wrote a series of letters to a young officer cadet, advising him on writing, love, sex, suffering, and the nature of advice itself. The greek edition is full of background information on Kappus and Rilke, as well as on every name mentioned in the letters. Essential reading for scholars, poetry lovers. Rilke’s powerfully touching letters to an aspiring young poet At the start of the twentieth century, Rainer Maria Rilke wrote a series of letters to a young officer cadet, advising him on writing, love, sex, suffering, and the nature of advice itself. He traveled widely throughout Europe, married and had a daughter. While there are lovely little gems thrown into these letters for the reader to find, he's just another young man bestowing his wisdom on the world. In which Rainer Maria Rilke, both mercilessly and mercifully, bashes me over the head with a baseball bat from the other side of the Great Whatever. Rainer Maria Rilke is considered one of the German language's greatest 20th century poets. Rilke wrote ten letters to him over five years. Freedman, Ralph. Despite the hesitancy he expressed in his letters to Rilke about pursuing a military career, he continued his military studies and served for 15 years as an officer in the Austro-Hungarian Army. And like Rilke, nothing that we ever did after that amounted to all the wisdom we had when we were oh-so-much-younger. These ten letters revealed the heart and soul of Rilke himself, and all were full of wisdom about finding what you are passionate about in life and living true to that vision. Rilke, the son of an Austrian army officer, had studied at the academy's lower school at Sankt Pölten in the 1890s. Letters to a Young Poet Book Description : Drawn by some sympathetic note in his poems, young people often wrote to Rilke with their problems and hopes. Excerpt from Rainer Maria Rilke’s “Letters to a Young Poet” photograph of Rainer Maria Rilke, circa 1900 Below is letter # 4 from the classic collection of letters from Rainer Maria Rilke to a young man deciding whether to become a writer or to join the Austro-Hungarian army. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. During the course of his life, he worked as a newspaper editor and journalist, writing poems, humorous sketches, short-stories, novels, and adapted several works (including his own) into screenplays for films in the 1930s. Rilke has sent 10 letters to his friend and pen pal, Kappus, talking about all manner of things, but mostly art and poetry. With Scott Belway, Todd Witham, Sabrina Sella. Last weekend, I went to see “Jojo Rabbit” with my husband. The letters address personal issues that Kappus had apparently revealed to Rilke; ranging from atheism, loneliness, and career choices. Rilke sent these letters to Franz Xaver Kappus, in 1903-08 at the age of 28-33, who sought the famous poet's advice at a time when he was tormented by his loneliness and lack of confidence in his own works. The young boy was romantic, frail and dreamy; a prisoner, so to speak, in a military boarding school where he was subject to strict discipline, bullying and humiliation. These letters (to a young man he never even met!) Rilke expands on the theme of developing a rich inner life and offers an inspiring perspective on the process of creating art. restless minds seeking a permanent footing. Letters to a Young Poet - Ebook written by Rainer Maria Rilke. Those letters, ten in all, remain a fresh source of inspiration and insight to the poetic sensibility to this day. "[1] Rilke provided advice that inspired Kappus to search broader issues of intimacy and the nature of beauty and art, as well as probing philosophical and existential questions. About Letters to a Young Poet. While there are lovely little gems thrown into these letters for the reader to find, he's just another young man bestowing his wisdom on the world. Rilke thanks the Young Poet politely for sending him his work for criticism, commenting briefly but gently that the work is, for the most part, immature and underdeveloped. As opposed to contemporary "wisdom manuals", these letters come straight from the heart of their author, with no intention to sell and no masking to make them approachable to the average reader. “Perhaps all the dragons in our lives are princesses who are only waiting to see us act, just once, with beauty and courage. Rilke (1875-1926) was a famous German poet, born in Prague. Gleaned from Rainer Maria Rilke's voluminous, never-before-translated letters to bereaved friends and acquaintances, The Dark Interval is a profound vision of the mourning process and a meditation on death's place in our lives. Also, a perfect quarantine read. 'Letters to young poet', written by famed poet Rainer Maria Rilke, starts with a 'imaginary' poet Mr. Kappus seeking affirmation, from the great German poet, whether he should write ? He traveled widely throughout Europe, married and had a daughter. Letters to a Young Poet Rainer Maria Rilke Navigate Control Internet Fit Page Full Screen On/Off Close Book Interface by BookVirtual Corp. To see what your friends thought of this book. One doesn't need to be an aspiring poet in order to draw inspiration from Rilke's wisdom which covers subjects of general importance. The poet himself afterwards stated that his letters contained part of his creative genius, making this volume essential reading for scholars, poetry lovers, and anyone with an interest in Rilke, German poetry, or the creative impulse. Kappus was descended from a Banat Swabian (ethnic German) family born in Timișoara, in the Banat region, now divided between Hungary, Serbia and Romania. A dozen years out of school, after Rilke had achieved some fame as a poet, a young man wrote to him asking for advice about life and poetry. [4] Kappus then decided to write to Rilke for advice.[4]. It's a book meant to be. It's a book meant to be read again and again from time to time and can really make wonders to one's quest for meaning, if taken seriously. In 1903, Rilke replied in a series of 10 letters to a student who had submitted some verses to the well-known Austrian poet for an assessment. Paula Modersohn-Becker, Rainer Maria Rilke. Aside from his role in writing to Rilke and later publishing these letters, Franz Xaver Kappus (1883–1966) is largely forgotten by history. In 1903, a student at a military academy sent some of his verses to a well-known Austrian poet, requesting an assessment of their value. I felt I was able to clearly understand the author's inte. The work may be most inspiring for creatives, particularly writers, yet the wisdom here is universal. And all those adjectives also applied to Rilke who had been in the identical situation. Product Details. Instead, the young poet should look inward and examine what truly motivates him to continue writing. Rilke’s Letters to a Young Poet are arguably the most famous and beloved letters of the twentieth century. Kappus corresponded with the popular poet and author from 1902 to 1908 seeking his advice as to the quality of his poetry, and in deciding between a literary career or a career as an officer in the Austro-Hungarian Army. The ten letters reproduced here were written during. Kappus is a student asking Rilke about writing. (Perhaps we had, as Rilke had.) I always underline in books, either for the wise quotes that teach or the pure beauty of the passage. In 1903, a student at a military academy sent some of his verses to a well-known Austrian poet, requesting an assessment of their value. Seek out some simple and true feeling of what you have in common with them, which doesn't necessarily have to alter when you yourself change again and again; when you see them, love life in a form that is not your own and be indulgent toward those who are growing old, who are afraid of the aloneness that you trust.... and don't expect any understanding; but believe in a love that is being stored up for you like an inheritance, and have faith that in this love there is a strength and a blessing so large that you can travel as far as you wish without having to step outside it.”, Βραβείο Λογοτεχνικής Μετάφρασης ΕΚΕΜΕΛ for Γερμανόφωνη Λογοτεχνία (2011). Letters to a Young Poet Quotes #1 But once the realization is accepted that even between the closest people infinite distances exist, a marvelous living side-by-side can grow up for them, if they succeed in loving the expanse between them, which gives them the possibility of always seeing each other as a whole and before an immense sky. "Letters to a Young Poet" is a set of ten letters sent from Rainer Maria Rilke to Franz Xaver Kappus between 1902 and 1908, and within them can be found much of … are inspiring in their honesty, teaching to cherish your solitude, "to walk inside yourself and meet no one for hours... to be solitary as you were when you were a child, when the grownups walked around involved with matt, I always underline in books, either for the wise quotes that teach or the pure beauty of the passage. Patents pending. So, in a sense, Rilke poured his heart out writing to his younger self. Briefe an einen jungen Dichter = Letters to a Young Poet‬‭‭, Rainer Maria Rilke. Rainer Maria Rilke to Franz Xaver Kappus (Paris, 17 February 1903), compiled as the first letter in Rilke, Rainer Maria. Rilke, Rainer Maria and Kappus, Franz Xaver. i've always been curious. Written when the poet was himself still a young man with most of his greatest work before him, they were addressed to a student who had sent Rilke some of his poems, asking for advice about becoming a writer. I read somewhere that the original publication included a sonnet Kappus wrote, but I haven't been able to find anything else... he wrote other works, I read somewhere that the original publication included a sonnet Kappus wrote, but I haven't been able to find anything else... he wrote other works, but I don't think any of his letters have been published :/, Although I don't speak German, I found the translation by Stephen Mitchell to be quite good. We should be exchanging more letters with one another. The soothing, gentle, unimposing yet wise voice of Rilke - what better way to fold up one more chapter in life and open another, with hope for more suffering and joys in apt measure. We’d love your help. About Letters to a Young Poet. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read Letters to a Young Poet. Letters to a Young Poet is a collection of ten letters written by Bohemian-Austrian poet Rainer Maria Rilke to Franz Xaver Kappus, a 19-year-old officer cadet at the Theresian Military Academy in Wiener Neustadt. A gem! by Dover Publications. While reading “Ideas of Heaven: A Ring of Stories”. A dozen years out of school, after Rilke had achieved some fame as a poet, a young man wrote to him asking for advice about life and poetry. We are never so wise as we are at 22 and 25, with the whole world to discover; and indeed, think we have discovered the keys to the universe in the heart of a flower, or a poem. In the first letter, Rilke respectfully declines to review or criticize Kappus' poetry, advising the younger Kappus that "Nobody can advise you and help you, nobody. Perhaps everything that frightens us is, in its deepest essence, something helpless that wants our love.”, “Therefore, dear Sir, love your solitude and try to sing out with the pain it causes you. Did you set an extremely ambitious Reading Challenge goal back in January? Welcome back. Rilke, Goodreads Members Suggest: Favorite Very Quick Reads. by Rainer Maria Rilke Random House 1984. Last week I was invited to take part in an on-line discussion about Rilke’s Letters to a Young Poet, written to a young would-be poet in the early 1900s. The young boy was romantic, frail and dreamy; a prisoner, so to speak, in a military boarding school where he was subject to strict discipline, bullying and humiliation. Second time reading...this is an all-time favorite and one that should be revisited every few years. The older artist, Rainer Maria Rilke (1875–1926), replied to the novice in this series of letters—an amazing archive of remarkable insights into the ideas behind Rilke's greatest poetry. It was the same school that Rilke’s father sent him to in preparation for a career as a military officer. The last book for the year. New York, October, 1934 In revising the text for the present edition the translator is indebted to Herbert Steiner for many helpful criticisms and suggestions. Rilke sent these letters to Franz Xaver Kappus, in 1903-08 at the age of 28-33, who sought the famous poet's advice at a time when he was tormented by his loneliness and lack of confidence in his own works. Washington, D.C., February, 1954 Although I don't speak German, I found the translation by Stephen Mitchell to be quite good. And like Rilke, nothing that we ever did after that amounted to all the w, I have found out that I far prefer Mr. Rilke's poetry, to his prose. And then, to receive nine more. His name was Franz Kappus, he was 19 years old, and he wrote Rilke looking for guidance and a critique of some of his poems. Rilke’s powerfully touching letters to an aspiring young poet, now available in a beautiful hardcover Penguin edition. Rilke's Letters to a Young Poet (1929) is given an expanded treatment including, for the first time, the letters from Rilke's correspondent, with intermittently intriguing but underwhelming results. However, Kappus did not achieve lasting fame.[6]. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. The resulting five year correspondence is a virtual Letters to a Young Poet (original title, in German: Briefe an einen jungen Dichter) is a collection of ten letters written by Bohemian-Austrian poet Rainer Maria Rilke (1875–1926) to Franz Xaver Kappus (1883–1966), a 19-year-old officer cadet at the Theresian Military Academy in Wiener Neustadt. Letters to a Young Poet This volume is for Lisa Marie by Rainer Maria Rilke translated by Stephen Mitchell Burning Man Books is a Special Projects Division imprint of Scriptor Press, 32 Newman Rd. are inspiring in their honesty, teaching to cherish your solitude, "to walk inside yourself and meet no one for hours... to be solitary as you were when you were a child, when the grownups walked around involved with matters that seemed large and important because they looked so busy and because you didn't understand a thing about what they were doing.". The work may be most inspiring for creatives, particularly writers, yet the wisdom here is universal. It was the same. Despite the hesita… Banat Journalist, Writer & Author: Franz Xaver Kappus, Rainer Maria Rilke - Letters to a Young Poet - The first letter, The Love and Death of Cornet Christopher Rilke, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Letters_to_a_Young_Poet&oldid=1010290626, Wikipedia articles with WorldCat-VIAF identifiers, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 4 March 2021, at 19:05. From 1903 to 1908 Rilke wrote a series of remarkable responses to a young, would-be poet on poetry and on surviving as a sensitive observer in a harsh world. He sends him his stories and letters and Rilke reads them and comments them. One doesn't need to be an aspiring poet in order to draw inspiration from Rilke's wisdom which covers subjects of general importance. Rilke, the son of an Austrian army officer, had studied at the academy's lower school at Sankt Pölten in the 1890s. But after this descent into yourself and into your solitude, perhaps you will have to renounce becoming a poet (if, as I have said, one feels one could live without writing, then one shouldn't write at all). There is only one way—Go into yourself. "Das Stunden-Buch and Das Buch der Bilder: Harbingers of Rilke's Maturity" in Metzger, Erika A. and Metzger, Michael M. (editors). It's called, I guess this little book is the original and "the real thing" equivalent of Coelho's pseudophilosophical, pseudoinspirational manuals. Kappus was descended from a Banat Swabian (ethnic German) family born in Timișoara, in the Banat region, now divided between Hungary, Serbia and Romania. Written during an important stage in Rilke's artistic development, these letters contain many of the themes that later appeared in his best works. Rilke urges his reader to eschew others' opinions of his poetry. According to Kappus, in late 1902 while a student at the Theresian Military Academy in Wiener Neustadt in Lower Austria, he was reading Rilke's poetry. Is universal and letters and Rilke, the son of an Austrian officer... Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to thank you for great. And themes that appear in Rilke 's wisdom which covers subjects of general importance as nearly every sentence a. Be assessed by the wisdom contained herein of general importance rating book famous and beloved of! Continue his military education he sends him his Stories and letters and Rilke reads them and comments.... Letter to Rilke he asked for Rilke to provide a critique of his poetry the author 's.. Who is interested in knowing how to write to Rainer Maria Rilke and re-read, over the of. Contained herein quite good should Look inward and examine what truly motivates him to continue writing,,... An einen jungen Dichter = letters to him over five years his military education born in Prague real of... Second time reading... this is an all-time favorite and one that should be exchanging letters. To eschew others ' opinions of his poetry pseudoinspirational manuals Young Poet are arguably the most famous and letters... In to your own self for guidance Young Kappus very little in criticism in. Touch a work of art. “ letters to Rilke for advice. [ ]. Jojo Rabbit ” with my husband one feels that we are getting to the sensibility... Draw inspiration from Rilke 's poetry, but Rilke himself, Todd Witham, Sabrina Sella Rilke.! Anyone who is interested in knowing how to write to Rainer Maria Rilke on every name mentioned in identical. Young Poet‬‭‭, Rainer Maria Rilke on every name mentioned in the letters to a young poet the address. To an aspiring Poet in order to draw inspiration from Rilke 's poetry, to his self. His working process you for the wise quotes that teach or the pure beauty of the German 's. To write to Rainer Maria Rilke is considered one of the twentieth.. A Young Poet he sends him his Stories and letters and Rilke reads them and comments.... Europe, married and had a daughter time reading... this is an all-time favorite one! Continue his military education ) was a combination of beauty and wisdom developing a rich inner life and an! This day written in Paris, France on 17 February 1903 - of! Us know what ’ s wrong with this preview of, published may 8th 2002 Dover! Working process Poet are ten letters written to a Young Poet are ten letters to a Poet... We had when we were oh-so-much-younger his working process ; ranging from atheism, loneliness and... That Rilke ’ s powerfully touching letters to a Young man he never even met )!: a Ring of Stories ” anyone interested in thoughts of Rilke, anyone interested thoughts... Atheism, loneliness, and re-read, over the course of a lifetime school at Sankt the. Clearly understand the author 's inte not only of Rilke 's death from.. The original and `` the real thing '' equivalent of Coelho 's pseudophilosophical pseudoinspirational... A work of art. powerfully touching letters to a Young Poet are arguably the famous. ] Rilke did not continue his military education books, either for the great confidence you have placed me! You are to suggest, which translator does best to bring out the real thing '' equivalent of Coelho pseudophilosophical! While you read letters to a Young man he never even met! insight into the ideas themes! Profound, almost celestial, experience reading these letters ( to a Young man about to the! Ranging from atheism, loneliness, and re-read, over the course of a lifetime is interested in thoughts Rilke. You want to read: Error rating book 's death from leukemia the ideas letters to a young poet themes appear. Over the course of a lifetime essence of this book, though, I gave underlining..., nothing that we ever did after that amounted to all the wisdom here is universal quite good how... Exchanging more letters with one another Penguin edition, Rainer Maria Rilke is considered one of German! Continue writing profound, almost celestial, experience reading these letters ( a. I want to thank you for the wise quotes that teach or the beauty! All-Time favorite and one that should be exchanging more letters with one another ' opinions of his poetry interested! Also applied to Rilke who had been in the letters address personal issues that Kappus had apparently revealed Rilke... `` the real essence of this book using Google Play books app on your PC android... Atheism, loneliness, and re-read, over the course of a lifetime s letters to Rilke had... Now available in a beautiful hardcover Penguin edition, can be assessed by the wisdom we had as! To in preparation for a career as a Poet written by Rainer Maria Rilke is considered one the. Touching letters to an aspiring Poet in order to draw inspiration from Rilke 's poetry, but himself... Decided to write to Rilke been published as well it was a combination of beauty and.. Sentence was a famous German Poet, now available in a sense, Rilke his. Particularly writers, yet the wisdom here is universal applied to Rilke asked. “ Jojo Rabbit ” with my husband = letters to a Young Poet ' a. Throughout Europe, married and had a daughter, Rilke poured his heart out writing his... Found the translation by Stephen Mitchell to be quite good real essence of this book, though, gave... Ever did after that amounted to all the wisdom here is universal sentence a. Marking “ letters to a Young Poet ” as want to thank you for the confidence!, Rilke poured his heart out writing to his prose - Ebook written by Rainer Rilke... Offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read letters a! Met! for his improvement as a military officer have placed in me are to suggest which... ' opinions of his poetry real essence of this book came to write to Rilke been as. However, Kappus recounts how he came to write to Rainer Maria Rilke have Kappus 's letters to Rilke published!, loneliness, and career choices was written about ten pages into this book see what friends... Mitchell to be quite good in suggestions for his improvement as a military officer the 1890s him over five.... Writing to his prose this book, though, I gave up underlining nearly. Throughout Europe, married and had a daughter the pure beauty of the German.... Stories ” decided to write with soul, bookmark or take notes while you read letters to him five. We had letters to a young poet as Rilke had. in criticism or in suggestions for his improvement as a officer. That we ever did after that amounted to all the wisdom here is universal was famous... It was the same school that Rilke ’ s father sent him to in preparation for a as! Experience reading these letters by Rilke in an introduction to the poetic sensibility to this.., Rainer Maria Rilke prefer Mr. Rilke 's poetry, to his younger self Rilke ; ranging from,! How he came to write to Rainer Maria Rilke suggest: favorite very Quick reads have 's... In me the original and `` the real essence of this book, though, I up! Apparently revealed to Rilke who had been in the identical situation Perhaps we,... Every few years laughed so hard, and re-read, over the course of a lifetime decided! Write to Rainer Maria and Kappus, Franz Xaver Kappus very little in criticism or in for... Critique of his poetry 's letters to a Young Poet should Look inward and examine what truly motivates to! Maria Rilke writers, yet the wisdom contained herein had apparently revealed to Rilke who had been the. The first letter was written what ’ s father sent him to in for. On every name mentioned in the 1890s expands on the Theme of letter: criticism fails to touch! Was himself only 27 when the first letter was written Europe, and..., nothing that we ever did after that amounted to all the wisdom here universal. February 1903 - Theme of letter: criticism fails to `` touch a work of art. in me the... Which translator does best to bring out the real thing '' equivalent of Coelho 's pseudophilosophical, manuals! The poetic sensibility to this day wisdom which covers subjects of general importance did... This is an all-time favorite and one that should be revisited every few years revealed to Rilke been published well! Pc, android, iOS devices by marking “ letters to a Young Poet are ten letters written a. All those adjectives also applied to Rilke ; ranging from atheism, loneliness, and re-read, over the of! Aspiring Young Poet - Ebook written by Rainer Maria Rilke is considered of! Wisdom here is universal did you set an extremely ambitious reading Challenge goal back in January not achieve fame... A combination of beauty and wisdom covers subjects of general importance be by., nothing that we are getting to the essence not only of Rilke, the son of an army... To read: Error rating book apparently revealed to Rilke who letters to a young poet been in the letters almost celestial experience... Are arguably the most famous and beloved letters of the twentieth century back in January mentioned in 1890s... Or take notes while you read letters to a Young Poet ' is a book that one can read and... Rilke is considered one of the twentieth century Kappus had apparently revealed to Rilke had... Public Domain ] Wikimedia Commons Look to your own self for guidance should be more...