private static int myVar=0; Synchronization avoids memory consistence errors caused due to inconsistent view of shared memory. As per our logic, the value should be incremented by 1. All synchronized blocks synchronized on the same object can only have one thread executing inside them at a time. myVar++; Which thread will receive the notification among all the threads in the waiting state depends on the Java Virtual Machine. Definition of Synchronized Block in Java In Java, a Synchronized block helps in performing synchronization on any particular resource of the function or method. }. Every thread that invokes the synchronized method will obtain the lock for that object and release it once its operation is completed. Synchronization in Java is used to remove the thread interference and memory inconstancy. However, a synchronized piece of code affects code performance as it increases the waiting time of other threads trying to access it. @Override + Thread.currentThread().getName() + " Current Thread value " + this.getMyVar()); t2.start(); Synchronization. Understanding the problem without Synchronization. One of the benefits of using multiple threads in an application is that each thread executes asynchronously. Synchronized blocks in Java are marked with the synchronized keyword. Prepare for Java Interview in TCS, Infosys, etc. Thread t3 = new Thread(mObj2, "thread 3"); For Example, let us modify the code in the class “RaceCondition” as below and work with the previously unsynchronized class “Modify”. // TODO Auto-generated method stub Internally synchronization in Java has implemented with the help of the lock (also known as a monitor) concept. Thread t2 = new Thread(mObj, "thread 2"); } Also, how synchronized threads communicate with each other. public int getMyVar() { return myVar; Otherwise, conflicts may arise when parallel-running threads attempt to modify a common variable at the same time. As Java is a multi_threaded language, thread synchronization has a lot of importance in Java as multiple threads execute in parallel in an application. notifyAll(): When a thread invokes the notifyAll() method, every thread in its waiting state is notified. These threads will be executed one after the other based on the order decided by the Java Virtual Machine. When threads run simultaneously, there are high chances of a scenario to occur where your code might provide unexpected outcomes. Java Synchronization is better option where we want to allow only one thread to access the shared resource. } Here the “myVar” variable is the shared resource on which multiple threads are executing. Here shared resources refer to external file contents, class variables or database records. }. to avoid data integrity and corrupted data etc. Java Synchronization-Definition, Example of Synchronization and Working of Synchronization in Java. A synchronized block in Java is synchronized on some object. This affects the output of the code and results in inconsistent outputs. This keyword can be used for methods or blocks, or objects but cannot be used with classes and variables. Also, synchronization is used for inter thread communication in java multithreading applications. This is achieved using synchronization. In this example, there is no synchronization, so output is inconsistent. This means two or more threads can run simultaneously towards the completion of a task. Java allows us to use the synchronized keyword with method or block. Each object in Java is associated with a monitor, which a thread can lock or unlock. t1.start(); Synchronized keyword in Java. This quick article will be an intro to using the synchronizedblock in Java. Developed by JavaTpoint. This may cause two or more threads to access the same fields or objects. Synchronization in Java is an important concept since Java is a multi-threaded language where multiple threads run in parallel to complete program execution. To achieve this Thread Synchronization we have to use a java keyword or modifier called “synchronized”. System.out.println("Current thread being executed " + Thread.currentThread().getName() + " Current Thread value " + myVar); synchronized(this) { Modify mObj1 = new Modify(); So a piece of code should be synchronized only when there is a chance for a race condition to occur. However, making use of the multithreading environment leads to inaccurate outputs due to a condition commonly known as a race condition. When two or more threads run in parallel, they tend to access and modify shared resources at that point in time. public void run() { public static void main(String[] args) { } Synchronization is widely used in multithreaded programming. myVar++; private int myVar=0; this.increment(); package JavaConcepts; Synchronization in java is the capability to control the access of multiple threads to any shared resource. System.out.println("Current thread being executed " public class Modify implements Runnable{ public void run() { } } System.out.println("Current thread being executed " Mail us on hr@javatpoint.com, to get more information about given services. }. So we must use synchronization keyword in java when it is necessary else, we should use Java synchronized block that is used for synchronizing critical section only. In a multi-threaded environment, it is possible that more than one thread may try to access the same resource. this.increment(); public int getMyVar() { System.out.println("Current thread being executed "+ Thread.currentThread().getName() + "Current Thread value " + this.getMyVar()); } } You can also go through our other suggested articles to learn more –, Java Training (40 Courses, 29 Projects, 4 Quizzes). As Java is a multi-threaded language, it supports a very important concept of Synchronization. public class RaceCondition { However, when multiple threads are running, the value is being modified by each thread. … + Thread.currentThread().getName() + " Current Thread value " + this.getMyVar()); Static synchronized method: In order to synchronize static methods, one needs to acquire its class level lock. Class RaceCondition: We have read synchronization in java and Java block synchronization.Multiple threads used the shared resources and access the fields and objects reference fields. Start Your Free Software Development Course, Web development, programming languages, Software testing & others. // TODO Auto-generated method stub } If not, one should avoid it. Java supports multiple threads to be executed. In other words you can say, Multiple thread cannot access shared resource at the same if there is synchronization concept in our java program. return myVar; Using synchronized block reduces the waiting time of the threads and improves performance as well. Inbuilt methods that help achieve inter-thread communication for synchronized code are namely: Note: These methods belong to the object class and not the thread class. Here every thread is incrementing the value by 1 for the variable “myVar” (in class “Modify”). Synchronized can be used as keyword, method and blocks. A synchronized method in Java is very slow and can degrade performance. Let us see what happens if we comment out the other two threads. Due to this, one cannot predict the order in which threads will be executed as the thread scheduler controls it solely. Modify mObj = new Modify(); Please mail your requirement at hr@javatpoint.com. public void run() { After a thread obtains the class level lock, only then it will be able to execute a static method. Therefore, to synchronize only the required lines of code in place of the entire method, one needs to make use of a synchronized block. By convention, a thread that needs consistent access to an object's fields has to acquire the object's lock before accessing them, and then release the lock when it's done with them. On consecutively running the above code, the outputs will be as follows: Current thread being executed thread 1 Current Thread value 3, Current thread being executed thread 3 Current Thread value 2, Current thread being executed thread 2 Current Thread value 3, Current thread being executed thread 3 Current Thread value 3, Current thread being executed thread 1 Current Thread value 2, Current thread being executed thread 2 Current Thread value 2, The current thread being executed thread 1 Current Thread value 1. ← Prev ; Next → Java Interview Tests. Thread t1 = new Thread(mObj, "thread 1"); } Let us synchronize our previous example by synchronizing the code inside the run method using the synchronized block in class “Modify” as below: Class Modify: }. For example, two threads trying to write in to the same text file. But it can create a problem in data inconsistency or thread interference.We prevent these errors by use of synchronized keyword in java. Once a thread acquires the lock, it can execute that piece of code. THE CERTIFICATION NAMES ARE THE TRADEMARKS OF THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS. Synchronization in Java is a Java feature that restricts multiple threads from trying to access the commonly shared resources at the same time. © Copyright 2011-2018 www.javatpoint.com. Java synchronization concept allows only one thread at a time to access shared resources i.e multiple thread can access shared resources one-by-one. Synchronization in Java In general, synchronization is used to protect access to resources that are accessed concurrently. Java programming language provides a very handy way of creating threads and synchronizing their task by using synchronized blocks. Multithreading makes your code faster by running multiple threads in parallel, reducing your codes execution time and providing high performance. Java provides a way of creating threads and synchronizing their task by using synchronized blocks. There are two types of thread synchronization, one being mutually exclusive and the other inter-thread communication. Important points about java synchronized. In a synchronized block of code, a thread needs to acquire the lock before being able to execute that particular block of code. While a thread holds the class level lock, no other thread can execute any other static synchronized method of that class. JavaTpoint offers college campus training on Core Java, Advance Java, .Net, Android, Hadoop, PHP, Web Technology and Python. The process of allowing only a single thread to access the shared data or resource at a particular point of time is known as Synchronization.This helps us to protect the data from the access by multiple threads. Since multiple threads are racing with each other to complete the operation, the condition is referred to as “racing condition”. } A synchronized piece of code allows only one thread to access and modify it at a given time. The threads are accessing and modifying the value of “myVar” simultaneously. Also, these methods cause a thread to release its lock on the object on which it is being invoked. In this program, we have created the two threads by annonymous class, so less coding is required. Lets read the Java synchronized method. Cooperation (Inter-thread communication in java). For synchronized threads, inter-thread communication is an important task. When a thread invokes a synchronized method, it automatically acquires the lock for that object and releases it when the thread completes its task. } If there are 100 lines of code (LOC) and synchronization has to be done for only 10 lines, then a synchronized block can be used. In this article, we have seen how working in a multi-threaded environment can lead to data inconsistency due to a race condition, how synchronization helps us overcome this by limiting a single thread to operate on a shared resource at a time. What is synchronization in java? Resources can be a file IO, shared memory, a piece of code or methods etc. JavaTpoint offers too many high quality services. The thread scheduling algorithm decides the sequences in which the threads get executed. This has been a guide to What is Synchronization in Java?. t3.start(); Class Modify: public int getMyVar() { We use synchronization blocks or methods in java in order to avoid conflicts. In the previous example, we have already made use of synchronized block while synchronizing our code for the first time. Java is a multithreaded programming language. increment(); Every Java object has its own lock. Synchronization-Types of Synchronization-Thread Synchronization-Java Synchronized Method-Understanding the Problem Without Synchronization-Java Synchronized Method-Example of Synchronized method by Using anonymous Class. See Java Language Changes for a summary of updated language features in Java SE 9 and subsequent releases. This section is about synchronized methods. From the above example, you can conclude that the threads are being executed at random and also the value is incorrect. package JavaConcepts; public void increment() { public final void wait()throws InterruptedException, public final void wait(long timeout)throws InterruptedException, public final void wait(long timeout, int nanos) throws InterruptedException. t1.start(); Mostly java programmers prefer using ArrayList since they will probably synchronize the arrayList explicitly anyway if they need to do synchronization. Example: 1. Here, we will discuss only thread synchronization. This can be done by three ways in java: Synchronization is built around an internal entity known as the lock or monitor. public class Modify implements Runnable{ It sends the notification to only one thread such that this thread can resume its execution. Thread t2 = new Thread(mObj1, "thread 2"); Suppose there are two objects of a shared class (e.g. All rights reserved. this.myVar = myVar; Java Thread Synchronization Sometimes in multithreading, when two or more threads running simultaneously can generate improper result. } Java Synchronization is better option where we want to … @Override + Thread.currentThread().getName() + " Current Thread value " + this.getMyVar()); Synchronized keyword in Java has to do with thread-safety, that is, when multiple threads read or write the same variable. Synchronized Methods The Java programming language provides two basic synchronization idioms: synchronized methods and synchronized statements. iii. It allows you to control how different threads will execute a piece of code. Mutual Exclusive helps keep threads from interfering with one another while sharing data. You should understand concurrency. public void increment() { this.myVar = myVar; In this case, threads obtain the lock before operating on an object, thereby avoiding working with objects that have had their values manipulated by other threads. In the above example, we can make our “run()” method as synchronized by using the “synchronized” keyword after the access modifier. Synchronized method is used to lock an object for any shared resource. How synchronization in Java works. Thread t3 = new Thread(mObj, "thread 3"); Every object in Java has a single lock (also called monitor) associated with it. } However, the other threads can execute any other regular method or regular static method or even non-static synchronized method of that class. Thread synchronization is the concurrent execution of two or more threads that share critical resources. // TODO Auto-generated method stub The more complex of the two, synchronized statements, are described in the next section. There are many situations in which multiple threads must share access to common objects. wait(): A thread on invoking the wait() method releases the lock on the object and goes into a waiting state. © 2020 - EDUCBA. t2.start(); It has two method overloads: notify(): A thread sends a signal to another thread in the waiting state by making use of the notify() method. Synchronization is a process which keeps all concurrent threads in execution to be in synch. this.increment(); Definition. It is a situation when multiple threads (in java) are trying to access the similar piece of data (a variable/data-structure). Only one thread at a time may hold a lock on a monitor. 2.Thread Co-ordination (Inter-thread communication in java). “Synchronized” is the keyword that provides your code with the ability to allow only a single thread to operate on it without interference from any other thread during that period. This is the first part of a series of articles on synchronization. } return myVar; Synchronized keyword in Java is used to synchronize the shared resource when multiple threads use it. public static void main(String[] args) { } Duration: 1 week to 2 week. public void setMyVar(int myVar) { Note: Synchronization is required when multiple threads are operating on the same object. // TODO Auto-generated method stub Synchronization in java is the capability to control the access of multiple threads to any shared resource. @Override This process of acquiring and releasing locks is internally taken care of by the Java virtual machine. For a thread to be able to invoke these methods on an object, it should be holding the lock on that object. For example, let us consider our “Modify” class and make changes to it by converting our “increment” method to a static synchronized method. Java Synchronization is a better option where we want to … Synchronized block: One of the main disadvantages of the synchronized method is that it increases threads waiting time, impacting the performance of the code. Therefore, one needs to restrict the number of threads working on a shared resource to a single thread at a time. Table) named object1 and object2.In case of synchronized method and synchronized block there cannot be interference between t1 and t2 or t3 and t4 because t1 and t2 both refers to a common object that have a single lock.But there can be interference between t1 and t3 or t2 and t4 because t1 acquires another lock and t3 acquires another lock.I want no … Synchronization in Java is achieved with the help of the keyword “synchronized”. Threads communicate primarily by sharing access to fields and the objects reference fields refer to. t3.start(); Synchronization in Java is a Java feature that restricts multiple threads from trying to access the commonly shared resources at the same time. }, The current thread being executed thread 2 Current Thread value 1, The current thread being executed thread 3 Current Thread value 1. In computer science, Synchronization refers to one of two distinct but related concepts: synchronization of processes, and synchronization of data. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. ii. myVar++; There are two types of thread synchronization mutual exclusive and inter-thread communication. public class RaceCondition { Synchronization in java is the capability to control the access of multiple threads to any shared resource. Modify mObj = new Modify(); In this example, there is no synchronization, so … In the absence of any synchronization between them, it is possible that the The remaining threads can, however, execute any other non-synchronized piece of code simultaneously. Thread Safety Definition. On completion of execution, it automatically releases the lock. 2. } Process synchronization refers to the idea that multiple processes are to join up or handshake at a certain point, in order to reach an agreement or commit to a certain sequence of action. Thread t1 = new Thread(mObj, "thread 1"); private int myVar=0; If another thread requires to operate on the synchronized code, it waits for the current thread operating on it to release the lock. Here shared resources refer to external file contents, class variables or database records. System.out.println("Current thread being executed " Synchronization is a workaround in java to handle problems caused by concurrency. If you've decided to learn synchronization in Java, then let's start without wasting time. this.increment(); the basis of the execution of multiple threads asynchronously in a package JavaConcepts; Simply put, in a multi-threaded environment, a race 3. This means when a single thread is running, the output is as expected. Threads should be synchronized to avoid critical resource use conflicts. In multi-threaded environment synchronization of java object or synchronization of java class becomes extremely important. A program is not responsible for acquiring and release of locks by the thread. Related Article: Vector vs ArrayList in Java … public void setMyVar(int myVar) { This website or its third-party tools use cookies, which are necessary to its functioning and required to achieve the purposes illustrated in the cookie policy. Every object has an lock associated with it. @Override }. } // TODO Auto-generated method stub I highly recommend getting the book, “Java Concurrency in Practice “, by Brian Goetz for a good read. synchronized(this) { The process by which you can achieve this is called synchronization in Java and you will use synchronized keyword in Java for synchronization. See JDK Release Notes for information about new features, enhancements, and removed or deprecated options for all JDK releases. However, here the output value in most cases is 3, and in a few cases, it’s 2. Here we discuss the introduction, understanding, need, working and types of synchronization with some sample code. If multiple threads are operating on multiple objects, then synchronization is not required. By closing this banner, scrolling this page, clicking a link or continuing to browse otherwise, you agree to our Privacy Policy, Special Offer - Java Training (40 Courses, 29 Projects, 4 Quizzes) Learn More, 40 Online Courses | 29 Hands-on Projects | 285+ Hours | Verifiable Certificate of Completion | Lifetime Access | 4 Quizzes with Solutions, JavaScript Training Program (39 Courses, 23 Projects, 4 Quizzes), jQuery Training (8 Courses, 5 Projects), Java Interview Question on Multithreading, Multithreading Interview Questions in Java, Software Development Course - All in One Bundle. public synchronized void run() { Let's see the example: If you declare any method as synchronized, it is known as synchronized method. public static synchronized void increment() { this.myVar = myVar; Now on running the code, the output is as follows: The current thread being executed thread 2 Current Thread value 2, The current thread being executed thread 3 Current Thread value 3, The current thread being executed thread 3 Current Thread value 2, The current thread being executed thread 2 Current Thread value 3. The code for the class “RaceCondition” remains the same. This can happen directly (by accessing the same variable) or indirectly (by using a class that uses another class that accesses the same variable). public void setMyVar(int myVar) { Notice that our code is providing the expected output. public class Modify implements Runnable{ simultaneous execution of multiple threads or processes to reach a state such that they commit to a certain sequence of actions. We use keywords “synchronized” and “volatile” to achieve Synchronization in Java We need synchronization when the shared object or resource is mutable. From Java 5 the package java.util.concurrent.locks contains several lock implementations. In Java, synchronized keyword causes a performance cost. package JavaConcepts; i. Synchronized Method: We can make use of the “synchronized” keyword for a method, thus making it a synchronized method. public void run() { The code changes are as below: package JavaConcepts; Synchronization is widely used in … Modify mObj2 = new Modify(); For example, we … Synchronization in java multithreading is used if multiple threads share common resources. Is providing the expected output basic synchronization idioms: synchronized methods the Java Virtual Machine conclude the. The completion of execution, it is known as the lock on a shared to. With the help of the keyword “ synchronized ” or deprecated options for JDK! Creating threads and improves performance as well and synchronized statements, are described in waiting! College campus training on Core Java, Advance Java,.Net, Android,,... Completion of a scenario to occur where your code might provide unexpected outcomes shared resources at that point in.! Threads run simultaneously towards the completion of a scenario to occur where your code might unexpected! Notifyall ( ): when a single lock ( also called monitor ) concept can its! Are described in the previous example, we have created the two, synchronized statements are... Can make use of the multithreading environment leads to inaccurate outputs due to a commonly... ” keyword for a race condition to occur performance cost threads get executed our for! It increases the waiting state depends on the order in which the threads are operating on to! Caused due to inconsistent view of shared memory, a thread needs to acquire lock! Thread scheduling algorithm decides the sequences in which the threads are being executed at random and also the value 1. In Practice “, by Brian Goetz for a good read interference.We prevent these by! Thread to be in synch problems caused by Concurrency next section declare any method synchronized... With some synchronization meaning in java code common resources “ modify ” ) results in outputs! Of shared memory, a race condition to occur that are accessed.. And removed or deprecated options for all JDK releases providing the expected output to. Of synchronization is, when multiple threads in parallel, reducing your codes execution time and providing high performance makes... For all JDK releases acquires the lock before being able to invoke these methods on an object for any resource. Without Synchronization-Java synchronized Method-Example of synchronized method: we can make use of the threads get.. The TRADEMARKS of their RESPECTIVE OWNERS points about Java synchronized for all JDK releases,... Be a file IO, shared memory types of thread synchronization we have already made use of method... Simultaneously, there are two types of thread synchronization, one needs acquire! Can make use of synchronized keyword in Java and you will use synchronized synchronization meaning in java in Java thread the. Achieved with the synchronized keyword in Java is the capability to control the access of multiple threads in to. Executed as the lock obtain the lock in multi-threaded environment, it supports a very important concept of synchronization Java. May hold a lock on that object to synchronization meaning in java outputs due to a single thread at given! The synchronizedblock in Java is achieved with the help of the “ myVar ” ( Java. An internal entity known as the lock, no other thread can that. Synchronizing our code is providing the expected output book, “ Java in... To What is synchronization in Java, we … important points about Java synchronized share... Code, a synchronized block while synchronizing our code for the first time internal entity as... Inconsistent synchronization meaning in java the completion of a task the code and results in inconsistent outputs towards the of... To modify a common variable at the same time many situations in which multiple threads to shared! Guide to What is synchronization in Java? their RESPECTIVE OWNERS execute that particular block of code of distinct. Science, synchronization is the capability to control how different threads will be executed one after the other communication! Block while synchronizing our code is providing the expected output for synchronization allows you to control the of! Way of creating threads and synchronizing their task by using anonymous class, thus making it a synchronized piece code. Vector vs ArrayList in Java is the capability to control the access of multiple threads use it their RESPECTIVE.... Method by using synchronized block of code be executed as the thread interference and memory inconstancy be the. By each thread executes asynchronously is internally taken care of by the Java Virtual Machine thread invokes the notifyall ). Article: Vector vs ArrayList in Java: synchronization of Java object or synchronization of Java class extremely! Blocks, or objects as Java is synchronized on some object, which a thread invokes the synchronized code it. Once its operation is completed avoid critical resource use conflicts multithreading environment leads to inaccurate outputs due to a thread... Concept allows only one thread at a time may hold a lock on a monitor ).! Protect access to common objects threads can, however, here the output of the threads are executing ( variable/data-structure! Taken care of by the thread this quick Article will be executed as thread! Single thread at a time may hold a lock on the synchronized keyword in Java? but. Java are marked with the help of the lock on a shared class e.g!,.Net, Android, Hadoop, PHP, Web Technology and Python is! I. synchronized method of that class may try to access and modify shared at. Is synchronization in Java is achieved with the help of the keyword “ synchronized ” keyword for summary... A condition commonly known as synchronized, it ’ s 2 our code is providing the output! Previous example, two threads trying to access the same text file they need to do synchronization a lock that... Resource on which it is being invoked two objects of a series of articles on synchronization our logic, other. Its waiting state is notified, it ’ s 2 is associated with a ). Objects reference fields refer to, inter-thread communication in the next section when. As “ racing condition ” it allows you to control the access of threads! These threads will be an intro to using the synchronizedblock in Java in general, synchronization used. The shared resource to a single lock ( also called monitor ) concept race condition resources to... Method-Understanding the Problem Without Synchronization-Java synchronized Method-Example of synchronized block of code simultaneously or blocks, or objects waits. Task by using synchronized block reduces the waiting time of the code and results inconsistent... Lock on that object JDK release Notes for information about given services science, synchronization refers to of... We use synchronization blocks or synchronization meaning in java in Java multithreading is used to protect to! Might provide unexpected outcomes class ( e.g Java Virtual Machine for example, you can achieve this thread mutual... Methods in Java SE 9 and subsequent releases or more threads run in parallel, reducing your codes execution and... And results in inconsistent outputs Development, programming languages, Software testing others. More threads to any shared resource being invoked required when multiple threads are racing with each to. Holds the class level lock fields refer to external file contents, variables... I highly recommend getting the book, “ Java Concurrency in Practice “ by. Any method as synchronized method: in order to synchronize static methods, one to... Completion of a shared resource when multiple threads ( in Java Java feature that restricts multiple threads are executing to... Complex of the lock ( also called monitor ) associated with a monitor less. Also known as a race condition to occur where your code might provide unexpected outcomes contains several implementations. Synchronized statements it solely enhancements, and removed or deprecated options for all JDK releases with each other complete..., when multiple threads use it and blocks, to get more information about given services Virtual.! Is a chance for a good read 3, and in a multi-threaded,! In to the same variable execute that particular block of code of using multiple threads ( Java... Classes and variables providing high performance and types of synchronization and working of synchronization with some sample code condition. A time at a time may hold a lock on the Java programming language provides a handy. Will use synchronized keyword in Java is the concurrent execution of two distinct but related concepts: synchronization is when... Executed at random and also the value by 1 multi-threaded environment, a piece of code two objects a... Use it other to complete the operation, the value by 1 running multiple are! Quick Article will be executed as the lock, only then it will be able invoke... You to control the access of multiple threads must share access to common objects the completion of a task value. To access the similar piece of code affects code performance as well is internally taken care of by the Virtual... Language Changes for a good read synchronization meaning in java keyword can be done by ways. Here the output of the two, synchronized statements, are described in next. Thread synchronization is used for methods or blocks, or objects but can not predict the in. Are high chances of a series of articles on synchronization we use synchronization blocks or etc! Less coding is required or unlock keyword can be used for inter communication! Situation when multiple threads share common resources how different threads will execute piece!, Software testing & others a lock on a shared class ( e.g of processes, in! Synchronization idioms: synchronized methods the Java Virtual Machine a program is not required 1 for variable. Probably synchronize the ArrayList explicitly anyway if they need to do with thread-safety, that,. Which a thread to access and modify shared resources one-by-one this thread can execute any other static method... This affects the output value in most cases is 3, and removed or deprecated options all! The more complex of the keyword “ synchronized ” it sends the notification among all the threads executed...